Please don't make circular designers fill out more forms

Europe is exploring Digital Product Passport requirements for furniture. This could be a remarkable opportunity for independent designers and small makers, provided we don't accidentally make circular design harder than producing something new.

There is something wonderfully contradictory about the circular design world. Some of the most inventive furniture being made today comes from designers who work with materials nobody originally intended for furniture, who transform discarded components into beautiful objects and who have built entire creative practices around questioning how things are produced. They are already challenging conventional manufacturing, experimenting with resourcefulness and proving that good design doesn't have to begin with virgin materials. Yet as Europe develops new sustainability requirements, I keep wondering whether the systems we create will recognise these different ways of working, or quietly expect everyone to operate like a conventional furniture manufacturer with a dedicated compliance department.

This question became particularly relevant while I was reviewing the Preparatory Study on Ecodesign for Furniture, specifically its Digital Product Passport Content Assessment, which is currently open for stakeholder feedback. The study forms part of the work supporting potential furniture requirements under the EU's Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR), and examines what information might be needed to support more sustainable products, better purchasing decisions, repair, reuse and other circular activities. Importantly, these are still draft assessments rather than final furniture-specific DPP requirements and the study explicitly acknowledges that feasibility, proportionality, costs and administrative burden require further assessment.

That last point deserves considerably more attention than it usually gets, because the difference between a useful digital tool and an administrative nightmare often lies in how well it understands the people expected to use it.

Not every piece of furniture starts with a perfectly documented material

Imagine a designer creating a beautiful stool from discarded bed slats (hmm…who would I be thinking about? ;-)), or a lighting designer transforming surplus industrial components into a limited collection. The resulting objects may be carefully considered, durable, repairable and genuinely desirable, but the materials themselves don't necessarily arrive with comprehensive technical documentation, perfectly traceable origins or detailed environmental datasets. Sometimes the designer knows exactly where a component came from; sometimes its previous history is incomplete, even though its characteristics and suitability for the new application can be assessed.

Now imagine asking that designer to reconstruct a level of historical material information that was never collected in the first place. The intention may be perfectly reasonable, but the practical result could be absurd: a designer who has successfully prevented useful materials from becoming waste is suddenly disadvantaged because those materials don't come with the documentation available to a manufacturer ordering new components through an established supply chain.

This doesn't mean recovered materials should be exempt from relevant safety requirements or that sustainability claims should go unquestioned. On the contrary, credible information is essential if circular furniture is to earn the confidence of architects, professional buyers and consumers. But there is an important difference between requiring reliable information about what a product is, how it performs and how it can be maintained, and demanding a complete historical record that may simply not exist.

A sensible system should be able to distinguish between verified information, documented estimates and genuinely unknown historical details. Transparency about uncertainty is far more useful than encouraging an appearance of precision that nobody can substantiate.

What if the passport actually helped designers sell their work?

This is where the discussion becomes much more exciting, because a well-designed Digital Product Passport could do something independent designers genuinely need: make their products easier to understand, trust, specify and choose.

One of the persistent challenges facing circular furniture is that the person considering it often needs more reassurance than they would when purchasing a conventional product. An interior architect may love the design but need to know whether it meets the project's technical requirements, how it should be maintained, whether parts can be replaced or how the materials will perform over time. A hospitality buyer might want confidence that an object can be repaired rather than replaced, while a future reseller may need reliable information about its maker, construction and previous interventions.

For a small designer, answering all these questions individually takes time, particularly when the same information has to be supplied repeatedly in different formats to different clients. Imagine instead that the relevant information could be documented once, made accessible to the right people and reused across professional specifications, procurement processes, maintenance and future resale. Rather than creating more work, the passport could gradually remove some of the repetitive explanations and uncertainty that currently make circular products harder to bring into projects.

And that could change the economics of circular design. Not because a QR code magically makes furniture more sustainable, but because reliable, accessible information can reduce the friction between an interesting object and someone willing to buy it.

For independent designers, that is a far more compelling proposition than compliance for compliance's sake.

The smallest businesses shouldn't need the biggest systems

Of course, none of this works if the solution requires every maker to purchase expensive software, learn a complicated data-management system or spend hours entering information that has little practical value to anyone. The furniture sector is enormously diverse, and the administrative capacity of an independent studio producing twenty objects a year is not comparable to that of an international manufacturer producing thousands of identical units.

The European study already examines information availability, data gaps, verification and barriers to data collection across the furniture value chain. That is encouraging, but I believe the experiences of micro-enterprises, independent designers and makers working with recovered materials deserve particular attention as the potential requirements are developed further.

We should be asking whether useful information can be captured naturally as part of the design and making process, whether shared infrastructure could make participation affordable, and whether the same data can serve multiple purposes without being entered again and again. We should also question which information genuinely creates value and which merely adds complexity.

The most useful systems won't be the ones with the greatest number of mandatory fields, but those that make it remarkably easy to share a small amount of trustworthy, relevant information and allow it to remain useful over time.

Let's build an advantage, not another obstacle

At May Again, we're exploring these questions through our work on object identity and continuity with participating independent designers. We're interested in how information about an object's origin, construction, care and subsequent transformations can remain connected to it as it moves into new environments and potentially new ownership. It's still experimental work, but one question keeps returning: how can we make the next life of an object easier without making the first life unnecessarily complicated?

I believe this is where the greatest opportunity lies for the furniture sector. Independent designers shouldn't have to become experts in regulatory databases to participate in a more circular economy. They should be able to focus on creating exceptional products, while accessible information systems help those products reach more people, enter professional projects, remain repairable and retain their relevance over time.

The Digital Product Passport could help establish the common information foundation for that future, although the practical value will depend on the requirements and the tools developed around them. If we get the balance right, we could give small makers something they rarely have enough of: visibility, credibility and easier access to markets that might otherwise overlook their work.

But if we get it wrong, we risk creating an extraordinary contradiction in which producing something new remains the easiest option, while making something valuable from what already exists becomes an administrative obstacle course.

The goal shouldn't be to make circular designers better at paperwork. It should be to make their work easier to choose.

And that, to me, is a much more exciting ambition for a Digital Product Passport.

May Again has contributed stakeholder feedback to the draft Digital Product Passport Content Assessment for Furniture, with particular attention to independent designers, recovered materials and the practical opportunities for circular furniture.

Read the study: Preparatory Study on Ecodesign for Furniture — Digital Product Passport Content Assessment, Phase I

Wendy Scheerlinck

Contemporary abstract print design studio from Belgium

https://www.houseofmay.eu
Next
Next

A Product Passport can survive its maker. But who keeps its story alive?